| Anderson, Chuck | CAL | C | I | 1948 | 40 | 6.00 | 220 | |||
| Anderson, Chuck | MON | G, E | I | 1949-50, 52 | 48, 82 | 6.00 | 220 | |||
| Anderson, Chuck | OTT | G, E | I | 1953 | 40 | 6.00 | 220 | |||
| Anderson, Tim | TOR | DB | I | 1971-74 | 26 | 6.00 | 205 | Aug. 1, 1949 | Colliers, WV | |
| Bledsoe, John | OTT | RB | I | 1974-75 | 30 | 6.01 | 218 | June 15, 1951 | ||
| Bledsoe, John | WPG | RB | I | 1973-74 | 30 | 6.01 | 218 | June 15, 1951 | ||
| Bobo, Hubert | HAM | FB | 1958 | 84 | 6.02 | 220 | July 2, 1934 | Athens,OK | ||
| Brown, Aaron | WPG | LB | I | 1982-84, 1988 | 52 | 6.00 | 235 | Jan. 13, 1956 | Warren, OH | More |
| Campana, Tom | SASK | SB | I | 1972-77 | 24 | 5.11 | 185 | Jan. 18, 1950 | More | |
| Cannavino, Joe | HAM | DB | I | 1963 | 20 | 5.11 | 185 | Jan. 20, 1935 | Cleveland, OH | |
| Cheatwood, Tim | EDM | DE | I | 2007 | 49 | 6.04 | 258 | Nov. 5, 1978 | East Cleveland, OH | |
| Cheatwood, Tim | HAM | DE | I | 2002-06 | 49 | 6.04 | 258 | Nov. 5, 1978 | East Cleveland, OH | |
| Clark, Don | MON | RB | I | 1960-63 | 21 | 5.11 | 190 | More | ||
| Clark, Don | OTT | RB | I | 1959 | 89 | 5.11 | 190 | |||
| Cooper, Joe | CAL | LB | I | 2002 | 95 | |||||
| Cope, Jim | MON | LB | 1975 | 62 | More | |||||
| Cotton, James | CAL | DE | I | 2001-02 | 99 | 6.3' | 250 | July 11, 1976 | Cleveland, OH | More |
| Cotton, James | HAM | DE | I | 2005-06 | 99 | 6.3' | 250 | July 11, 1976 | Cleveland, OH | More |
| Cousineau, Tom | MON | LB | I | 1979-81 | 45 | 6.03 | 227 | May 16, 1957 | Fairview Park, OH | |
| Curcillo, Tony | HAM | LB, QB | I | 1956-58, 60 | 99 | 6.01 | 200 | May 27, 1931 | Long Branch, NJ | |
| DeGraffenreid, Allen | WPG | WR | I | 1996 | 81 | 6.03 | 200 | May 1, 1970 | Columbus, OH | More |
| Dulin, Gary | OTT | DT | I | 1982-84 | 69 | 6.04 | 275 | Jan. 20, 1957 | Madison, KY | More |
| Dulin, Gary | SASK | DT | I | 1985 | 70 | 6.04 | 275 | Jan. 20, 1957 | Madison, KY | More |
| Dulin, Gary | TOR | DT | I | 1985 | 6.04 | 275 | Jan. 20, 1957 | Madison, KY | More | |
| Fields, Jerry | MON | QB | I | 1963-64 | 15 | 6.00 | 225 | |||
| Galbos, Rick | CAL | RB | I | 1973-77 | 21 | 6.01 | 205 | |||
| Galbos, Rick | MON | RB | I | 1977 | 34 | 6.01 | 205 | |||
| Gordon, Denman (Sonny) | HAM | DB | I | 1989-90 | 18 | 5.11 | 195 | July 30, 1965 | Lynn, Mass | |
| Gordon, Denman (Sonny) | SASK | HB | i | 1991 | 16 | |||||
| Guess, Mike | BC | DB | I | 1980 | 17 | 5.11 | 188 | Apr. 20, 1958 | Columbus, OH | |
| Harper, Roger | BC | S | I | 1999 | 24 | 6.02 | 225 | Oct. 26, 1970 | Columbus, OH | |
| Hicks, Tyrone | SASK | WR | I | 1980 | 14 | |||||
| Holland, Jamie | SASK | WR | I | 1995 | 8 | 6.01 | 192 | Feb. 1, 1964 | Raleigh, NC | |
| Holland, Jamie | WPG | WR | I | 1994-95 | 1 | 6.01 | 192 | Feb. 1, 1964 | Raleigh, NC | |
| Jackson, Stanley | MON | QB | I | 1999-2000 | 5 | 6.02 | 210 | 3/24/1975 | Paterson, NJ | |
| Jackson, Stanley | TOR | QB | I | 2001-02 | 16 | 6.02 | 210 | Mar. 24, 1975 | Paterson, NJ | |
| Jackson, Stanley | WPG | QB | I | 2004 | 8 | 6.02 | 210 | Mar. 24, 1975 | Paterson, NJ | |
| Jemison, Thad | OTT | WR | I | 1985 | ||||||
| Jemison, Thad | TOR | WR | I | 1985 | 14 | |||||
| Johnson, Brent | BC | DE | N | 2001-07 | 97 | 6.02 | 265 | Dec. 7, 1976 | Kingston, ON | |
| Johnson, Kevin | CAL | LB | I | 1999-01 | 44 | 6.00 | 240 | Dec. 27, 1972 | Winder, GA | |
| Johnson, Kevin | MON | LB | I | 2002-05 | 44 | 6.00 | 240 | Dec. 27, 1972 | Winder, GA | |
| Leach, Scott | BC | LB | 1989 | 76 | ||||||
| Lindsey, Kelvin | HAM | RB | I | 1984 | 33 | |||||
| MacCready, Derek | BC | DL | N | 1989-93 | 78 | 6.05 | 260 | May 4, 1967 | Montreal, QB | More |
| MacCready, Derek | EDM | DL | N | 1996-98 | 79 | 6.05 | 260 | May 4, 1967 | Montreal, QB | More |
| MacCready, Derek | HAM | DL | N | 1999 | 79 | 6.05 | 260 | May 4, 1967 | Montreal, QB | More |
| MacCready, Derek | OTT | DL | N | 1994-95 | 74, 75 | 6.05 | 260 | May 4, 1967 | Montreal, QB | More |
| Machinsky, Francis | TOR | G | I | 1956 | 63, 69 | 6.00 | 215 | New Salem, PA | ||
| Marshall, Jim (a) | SASK | T , DE | 1959 | 58 | 6.03 | 235 | Dec. 30, 1937 | Danville, KY | ||
| McClellion, Central | BC | DB | I | 2000 | 34 | 6.00 | 190 | Sept. 15, 1975 | Delray Beach, FL | More |
| McCullough, Deland | WPG | RB | I | 1998-99 | 20 | 5.11 | 205 | Dec. 1, 1972 | Allegheny, PA | More |
| Mitchell, David | OTT | DB | I | 2003 | 33 | |||||
| Murphy, Rob | BC | T | I | 2006-08 | 56 | 6.05 | 310 | Jan. 18, 1977 | Buffalo, NY | More |
| Murphy, Rob | TOR | T | I | 2009 | 56 | 6.04 | 307 | Jan. 18, 1977 | Buffalo, NY | |
| Olive, Bobby | HAM | WR | I | 1998 | 88 | 6.00 | 167 | Apr. 22, 1969 | Paris, TN | |
| Pagac, Fred | OTT | TE | 1977 | 35 | 6.01 | 220 | Apr. 26, 1952 | Brownsville, PA | ||
| Powell, Craig | BC | DL | I | 2002-03 | 56 | 6.04 | 230 | Nov. 31, 1971 | Youngston, OH | |
| Provost, Ted | SASK | S | I | 1973-77 | 10 | 6.02 | 195 | July 26, 1948 | Navarre, OH | |
| Rambo, Ken-Yon | CAL | WR | I | 2005-09 | 85 | 6.01 | 195 | Oct. 4, 1978 | Cemtos, CA | |
| Roberts, Michael | HAM | DB | N | 2007-08 | 27 | 5.11 | 185 | Sept. 16, 1983 | Hamilton, ON | |
| Schlichter, Art | OTT | QB | I | 1988 | 10 | 6.03 | 210 | Apr. 25, 1960 | Washington Court House, OH | |
| Schmidin, Paul | HAM | DL | 1970 | 70 | ||||||
| Scott, Bo | OTT | RB | I | 1964-68 | 16 | 6.03 | 215 | Mar. 30, 1943 | Connellsville, PA | More |
| Shaw, Bob | CAL | E | I | 1951-53 | 60 | 6.04 | 226 | May 22, 1921 | Richwood, OH | More |
| Shaw, Bob | TOR | E | I | 1953 | 77 | 6.04 | 226 | May 22, 1921 | Richwood, OH | More |
| Simmons, Jason | HAM | DT | 1994 | 96 | ||||||
| Skillings, Vince | MON | DB | I | 1981-83 | 30 | 5.11 | 183 | May 3, 1959 | Brenizer, PA | |
| Stanley, Dimitrious | WPG | 1998 | 83 | |||||||
| Stillwagon, Jim | TOR | DT | I | 1971-75 | 68 | 6.00 | 239 | Feb. 11, 1949 | Mt. Vernon, OH | |
| Sutherin, Don | HAM | DB, K | I | 1958, 60-66 | 22 | 5.10 | 193 | Feb. 29, 1936 | Empire, OH | More |
| Sutherin, Don | OTT | DB, K | I | 1967-69 | 14 | 5.10 | 193 | Feb. 29, 1936 | Empire, OH | More |
| Sutherin, Don | TOR | DB, K | I | 1970 | 12 | 5.10 | 193 | Feb. 29, 1936 | Empire, OH | More |
| Tidmore, Sam | HAM | DE | I | 1964 | 71 | 6' 1 | 230 | Oct. 28, 1938 | Decantur, IL | |
| Trivisonno, Joe | TOR | HB | 1958 | 98 | 5.11 | 214 | ||||
| Ulmer, Ed | OTT | DB, P | I | 1963-64 | 23 | 6.02 | 195 | |||
| Ulmer, Ed | WPG | DB, P | I | 1965-71 | 22, 24 | 6.02 | 195 | |||
| Vargo, Ken | OTT | LB | 1956-58 | 41, 43 | 6.01 | 200 | Martin's Ferry, OH | |||
| Vicic, Don | BC | FB | I | 1957-64 | 36 | 6.02 | 215 | |||
| Washington, Alvin (Al) | OTT | LB | I | 1983-86 | 17 | 6.03 | 225 | Sept. 25, 1958 | Erie, PA | More |
| Wayne, Clinton | EDM | DT | N | 2005, 08 | 93 | 6' 3 | 280 | May 17, 1977 | Scarborough, ON | |
| Wayne, Clinton | HAM | DT | N | 2007-08 | 90 | 6.02 | 280 | May 17, 1977 | Scarborough, ON | |
| Wayne, Clinton | MON | DT | N | 2005-06 | 90 | 6.03 | 280 | May 17, 1977 | Scarborough, ON | |
| Wayne, Clinton | OTT | DT | N | 2002-04 | 90 | 6.03 | 280 | May 17, 1977 | Scarborough, ON | |
| Zizakovic, Srecko | CAL | DE | N | 1990-95 | 96 | 6.05 | 255 | Aug. 13, 1966 | Weston, ON | More |
